What if Judas Had Waited 3 More Days?

What if Judas Had Waited 3 More Days?

June 14, 2025•11 min read


The Grief That Lingers for Those Who Could Have Come Back


When The Question Finds You at 4am

The wind screamed against the windows.

Thunder cracked close… too close.

I was half-awake, tangled in sheets and sleep, a scared little girl curled against my side like I was the safest place on earth.

It was 4 a.m., that strange, spiritual hour where everything feels louder and heavier and more real.

And then, out of nowhere, the question hit me like a stone:

Did Judas go to hell?


Did Judas go to hell?


I wasn’t prepared for the weight of it.

I was holding a child, exhausted, blinking through sleep, and suddenly I was grieving a man who betrayed the Son of God.

Not just because of what he did.

But because I understood him.

Because somewhere beneath the theology and the betrayal and the silver coins, I could feel the ache of a soul that believed it was too late.

And I couldn’t stop thinking about him.

Not as a villain.

But as someone who was so close to mercy, and didn’t come back.


The Betrayer Who Could’ve Been Me: Why Judas Still Wrecks Me

Sometimes the heartbreak isn’t the betrayal.

It’s the fact that someone didn’t believe they could be forgiven.

That’s what wrecks me about Judas.

He was there for the miracles.

He touched the bread that multiplied.

He watched blind men open their eyes and the dead sit up and breathe again.

He heard the words, “I am the Way, the Truth, the Life.”

And he still… couldn’t believe grace was meant for him, too.


Judas at the Table: When Guilt Feels Louder Than Grace


I think about that a lot.

About how his feet were washed by the same hands that formed galaxies.

How he sat at the table and dipped his bread into the same oil as the Savior of the world.

How the Son of God called him “friend” with full knowledge of the betrayal that was already in motion.

And still…

Judas walked away.

Not just from Jesus.

But from mercy.

From restoration.

From the one thing that could’ve unwrapped the noose from around his soul.


What Shame Does to a Soul: Judas and the Weight of Remorse


I wonder if he cried when he walked out.

I wonder if his chest burned when he saw Jesus turn toward him in the garden.

I wonder if his hands trembled when the cold silver clinked in his palm.

I wonder if the sound haunted him after, like a death knell echoing in his ears.

I wonder if the guilt came fast and hot,

the kind that leaves your skin cold and your mouth dry and your heart pounding against your ribs like it’s trying to escape your body.

That’s the thing about shame.

It doesn’t come with clean lines.

It comes like a flood you can’t stop,

and suddenly you’re choking on guilt you can’t swallow down.


Remorse Without Return


He felt it.
We know he did.

The Bible says he was seized with remorse.
Not a passing guilt.
Not a twinge of regret.
But a full-body collapse, the kind of sorrow that suffocates.

I imagine his hands shaking as he gripped the silver.
The weight of it suddenly unbearable.
Cold. Heavy. Loud.

Maybe it didn’t sound like money anymore.
Maybe it sounded like betrayal.
Like blood.
Like every miracle he’d witnessed collapsing into a pile of coins he couldn’t return fast enough.

He took them to the temple,
The place meant for mercy,
And still couldn’t see himself as someone worth saving.

Maybe the priests wouldn’t look at him.
Maybe they did.
Maybe they saw the panic in his eyes and backed away.
Maybe he screamed.
Maybe he whispered.
Maybe he didn’t say anything at all, just opened his palm, let the silver fall, and ran.

But not toward Jesus.

Not toward the upper room.
Not toward the shoreline like Peter.
Not even toward the cross.

He ran to silence.

To isolation.
To a rope.
To a lie that said this was the only way to make it stop.

And that’s the grief I can’t shake.
Because the cross was already breaking open behind him.
Mercy had already been set in motion.
But Judas couldn’t see it.

He didn’t stay long enough to hear Jesus say, “It is finished.”
He finished it himself.


Three More Days: The Redemption He Didn’t Wait For


And I can’t help but weep for him.

He was so close to redemption.

So close to resurrection.

So close to hearing Jesus whisper his name again.

If he had just waited.

Three. More. Days.

Three days… and the tomb would’ve split wide open.

Three days… and he’d have seen the blood still covers betrayal.

Three days… and maybe he would’ve run like Peter...

Not to a rope.

But to grace.

But he didn’t.

He let shame speak louder than the Savior he once followed.

He let the voice of condemnation become his final authority.

And the rope that took his life wasn’t just tied around his neck.

It was wrapped around a lie: that what he did was unforgivable.


When We Choose Distance Instead of Confession


And maybe what breaks me the most...

is that I’ve seen people do the same thing.

Not with rope.

But with silence.

With self-righteousness.

With avoidance.

With performance that keeps their hands busy and their hearts numb.

I’ve seen people walk away from the very grace that could have restored them.

because coming back would mean admitting they were wrong.

They’d rather keep pretending than break in front of a holy God.

They’d rather spin the story than confess the sin.

They’d rather act like Judas didn’t matter, because acknowledging him would mean acknowledging the parts of them that look just like him.


I’ve Failed Jesus Too… And That’s Why This Hurts


And I get it.

Because I’ve been there.

I’ve been the one who failed Him.

I’ve made promises I didn’t keep.

I’ve run when I should’ve knelt.

I’ve felt the heat of shame crawl up my neck and the sting of tears I didn’t want to cry.

I’ve heard the whisper:

“You can’t come back from this.”

But I did.

And maybe that’s why Judas makes me cry.

Because I know what it cost to come back.

And I wish… God, I wish… he had known it was still possible for him too.


This Isn’t Just About Judas | It’s About the Ones Still Running


This isn’t just grief over a man who lived 2,000 years ago.
This is grief for every person today still carrying what Jesus already died to take.
Grief for the ones who ghosted grace.
The ones who hurt people and never apologized.
The ones who burned bridges and called it “boundaries.”
The ones who post Scripture but won’t answer the phone.
The ones who smile big at church but can’t sleep through the night.
The ones who blame God for the fallout of choices they never owned.

This is for the ones who think they’ve gone too far.
The ones who know they’re wrong, but can’t stand to be seen kneeling.
The ones who are so sure they can’t be loved anymore…
they don’t even try to return.

And God help me... it breaks my heart.
Because the door is still open.
And shame is still lying.
And mercy is still whispering, “You’re not too late.”


Judas Was Human, And That’s Why I Still Cry


Judas doesn’t make me cry because he was evil.

He makes me cry because he was human.

Because he was close.

Because he could’ve come home.

And he didn’t.

And that’s the kind of grief that doesn’t leave easily.

It lingers in the soul.

It shows up in the middle of the night.

It weeps… not just for what happened, but for what could’ve been redeemed.

We’ll never know what could’ve happened if Judas had come back.

That’s between him and God.

But what we do know is this:

Remorse is not the same as repentance.

Guilt isn’t the same as grace.

And walking away doesn’t have to be the end of the story.

Judas shows us what happens when we refuse to believe God’s forgiveness is real.

When we refuse to receive what Jesus already paid for.

When we let shame speak louder than mercy.

And I feel it in the deepest part of me because Judas was still invited.

Jesus called him friend.

Even knowing what was coming.

Even knowing that betrayal had to happen for salvation to be fulfilled.

He still deserved forgiveness.

Just like you do.

Just like I do.

But forgiveness is only life-giving when we’re willing to accept it.

And that’s where a lot of people get stuck.

Because God has already forgiven them…

But they haven’t forgiven themselves.

And I think as human beings with human understanding we struggle to accept the concept that God can and will forgive us because we can’t make it make sense in our head what that kind of love looks like. Because it’s a love beyond our human understanding.

So they live like Judas, haunted, heavy, halfway convinced it’s too late.

All while heaven is still whispering, ‘You can still come home.’


We’ve All Been Judas


Let’s be honest.

If you’re walking with Jesus now…

and you weren’t before…

Then you know exactly what this means.

You’ve felt the weight of regret.

You’ve heard the lie that it’s too late.

You’ve wondered if what you did disqualified you.

Because at some point...

We’ve all been Judas.

We’ve all betrayed what we knew was right.

We’ve all chosen sin over surrender.

We’ve all reached for silver instead of the Savior.

The difference is what happened next.

Some ran back like Peter.

Some stood still like Thomas.

And some walked away like Judas… and never returned.

But if you’re reading this right now...

You didn’t walk away.

You came back.

You let grace catch you.

And you know the cost of that kind of comeback.


You Can Still Come Back, Don’t Let Shame End Your Story


So if you’re Judas right now...

If you’re hiding, performing, spinning, or weeping in silence:

Please don’t run.

Don’t let guilt name you.

Don’t let shame be your final word.

Jesus already said the last word over your life: “It is finished.”

The cross covered it.

The tomb broke it.

And the door is still open.

But you have to come back.

Please don’t let your story end three days too soon.

And if you’re loving someone who’s still running…

Don’t stop praying.

Don’t stop hoping.

Jesus still calls them friend.


Disclaimer:

This blog post is based on my personal experiences, reflections, and spiritual insights. It is not intended to defame or harm any individual or organization. All descriptions are personal opinion and perception, and no names or identifying details have been shared.


📝 5 Days of Holy Grit – Portable prompts for when grace feels far away and you need a comeback.
🙏 Recovery Prayer Pack – Five powerful prayers for the days shame won’t shut up.

And if you’re still carrying what Jesus already died to take…


📚 Read one of the latest posts.


💔 Sit with it. Let it crack something open.

➡️ Grieving Egypt: The Pain of Leaving Spiritual Bondage Behind – June 7, 2025
➡️ Season Recap: Faith, Failure, and Finding God in the Mess – May 31, 2025
➡️ It Wasn’t All Good. It Wasn’t All Bad. It Was Just Real – May 25, 2025
➡️ The Mountain Didn’t Move—We Climbed It – May 17, 2025

🌿 You don’t have to be perfect.
🕊️ You just have to be willing to come back.

Before You Go

If this post met you somewhere, let’s stay connected. I go even deeper on Substack, and you can listen to the Letters From a Christian Seer podcast on Apple Podcasts. New here? Read my story.

Building something of your own? See how we can work together.

Keep Reading

Keep Walking This Road With Me

Join the Holy Grit email list for honest weekly letters on recovery, grace, and the real places Jesus meets us.

Join the Weekly Letters


If you came for the deep end, thanks for wading in. And if God's also nudging you to build something, I made a free LLC checklist to get you started. When you're ready for the full walkthrough, there's the $27 LLC guide, and a $47 LLC Guide Walkthrough Call if you get stuck.

Back to Blog